Homeschooling…Is It For Me??

Now that Katelyn is the ripe, old age of almost five we are having to start thinking about schooling for her. As much as I want to hide my head in the sand and pretend she’s not getting old enough for school already, I can’t. This year she will go to “Kindergarten” at the private school she went to Pre-K for last year. But technically she isn’t old enough to go to Kindergarten so if we put her in public school next year, she’ll have to do Kindergarten again. We are considering homeschooling next year. It’s a big decision and one we aren’t taking lightly. In fact, I’m glad I don’t have to make that decision just yet!

We were homeschooled until Junior High and ended up skipping grades because we were ahead.  Our situation was a little different since we were missionaries to Brazil and came back to the USA every couple of years on furlough. During that time we’d travel all over the country visiting churches. Homeschooling gave my parents the flexibility they needed to continue our education while traveling all over. They also wanted us to have an American, Christian education and felt this was the best option all around at the time while living in Brazil.

Many of my cousins were homeschooled and did just as well. I’ll have to admit to dreaming about going to school once I started getting older. It seemed like such an awesome thing! Well, once I did start going to an American, Christian school it didn’t end up being all that I had dreamed that’s for sure.

Anyway, I survived and feel like I have a unique view on both sides of the homeschooling versus public schooling debate.

I’ve noticed that homeschooling has become a lot more popular these days. Even non Christians are doing it. It used to be a “Fundametalist Christian” thing and now everybody is doing it for different reasons.  However, depending on where you live it can be popular or not so popular.

If I were to homeschool I’d be the only person in my area that I know that’s doing it. No one in my church homeschools (as far as I know) and none of my friends do here in Massachusetts.  I wouldn’t have much family support here for it either as my husband’s family don’t seem to be supportive of the idea or like it much. My family thinks it’s great but they’re all the way in Texas!

I know there’s a certain stigma that goes with homeschooling: socially awkward children, education depending on the quality of the parent’s teaching skills , narrow minded, fundamentalist, and children unable to function in society. Comments like ” Ooh, they’re homeschooled. Thaaat’s why.”

However, there are so many options that homeschooling families have today to cover all the social and education bases that things that once seemed like huge obstacle, aren’t anymore. Things like extra curricular activities, sports, clubs and lots of social interaction at church. ( If you’re a church going family, that is).

So, needless to say this is something I’m praying my heart out about right now. My husband is kind of letting me take the lead on this since I’d be the one doing most, if not all, of the educating.

My Top Ten today deals with questions/ fears I have about homeschooling and the reasons why I want to do it.

1.What if I can’t explain a concept very well to her and she is not getting it?

2. What if I find homeschooling a certain someone very frustrating and don’t have the patience for it?

I have worked with her on preschool and pre-k concepts and we can really butt heads!

3.What if she hates it and begs to go to school like all of her friends?

4. Will people stop and ask us why my kids aren’t in school like they did us?

Whenever my mom used to take us out to the store or to run an errand  during school hours when we were back on furlough some nosy person would inevitably ask why we weren’t in school at the moment. So my mom had to launch into the homeschooling explanation and then the missionary explanation. I used to die of embarrassment.It got to the point where many times we just stayed home until school was out just to avoid the nosy questions. I preferred it that way! I know that’s not a big deal now and most people probably wouldn’t ask.

5. What curriculum is the best and most simple to teach?

6. What if I feel a continual lack of support in doing this? Like we’re the odd ones out?

I can’t stand nosy, contrary people and I don’t want or feel the necessity to constantly explain myself all the time about our choice. I know for some people homeschooling is a hot topic and they are almost offended by the idea. I’ve seen many parents act as if I’m saying they aren’t good parents because they put their kids in public school.

7. Will my girls feel like they “stuck out” like I did because we were homeschooled?


Reasons why I’m considering homeschooling:

8. My children would get a Christian based education here at home. We would teach them the values we believe in and Creation based science concepts.

9. I like the simpler, slower. flexible pace of homeschooling. There would be no rushing to school in the morning and then rushing out to pick my kids up. There would be no trekking through the snow every morning with all of our gear. In and out. In and out. I feel like the time spent learning would be more efficient.

10. There is lots of one on one attention in homeschooling. Smaller class size for sure!


Do you homeschool? Are you planning on homeschooling?

On the flip side: Do you hate homeschooling and think it’s a terrible idea?

I’d love hear from all of you!

For more Top Ten Tuesday check out Oh Amanda!

Comments

  • Lmlafleur

    I have to admit I would never have the patience to homeschool both girls. Kaitlyn and I are too much alike and we tend to really butt heads! If you are really thinking about homeschooling there could be some internet based groups for homeschooling parents that could provide a good support base for you. I know you will make the right decision no matter what. :0)

  • Woolbright52

    I think that homeschooling is looked at differently now. I don't think you would have all the questions that we used to get now. I'm sure you will make the right decision when the time comes.

  • lidandthekids

    I think you should research homeschool co-ops in your area. You might be surprised to find some. I would definitely think there would be some in the Boston area. I know that's not super close to you, but it would be a group you could do something with on a monthly basis or so. Just a thought. I say you do what you think feels right for you and your girls. If you do it for a year and it really was not what you were wanting, then you could just put her back in public school. But you may really like it. I personally couldn't homeschool Garrett unless it was necessary. We are too much alike and it would not end well. But if for some reason I needed to, I would do it in a heartbeat. Good luck!

  • givinguponperfect

    I don't plan to homeschool. But if you are looking into it, the beauty of this day and age (ack! That makes me sound so old!) is that you have soooo many resources at your fingertips with the internet!

  • http://twitter.com/notdiyheather Heather

    We are considering homeschooling as well, but have 2 more years before we really need to decide. (This year, LB is going to preschool at our church.) If we homeschool, I know we will participate in the local homeschool association. They have classes one day a week where all the homeschool families get together. The kids can take elective classes with their peers. It's really a great addition.

    I worry about the butting of heads as well. But I also remember what I learned in Ed.Psych. Ages 3 and 4 are ROUGH. They are going through some many developmental changes. The rapid transitions slow down a bit at age 5.

    Good luck with your decision!

  • http://www.itscome2this.com mandi@itscome2this

    So many things to think about! I'm in a similar boat – Evan will go through “K” at the Preschool he's been out, but then he'll repeat K again next year – either in public, private or homeschool. All I can say is I'm researching it all. I want to tour schools, ask questions, look at curriculum, etc. etc. I want to find out what type of discounts & breaks we can get for private & just see what are possibilities are. I'm closing nothing off until I've looked into everything … I'm a nervous wreck already!! I will agree though about all the options available. I had no idea so many co-ops or alternatives were available in my town until I really started digging. Maybe you'll be pleasantly surprised!

  • http://idreamofclean.net Idreamofclean

    Since I only have a one year old I haven't thought much about this subject. But I did want to comment to say how cool it is that you lived in Brazil for so long. My husband has been over there several times and we have such a heart for brazillians. We'd love to adopt from there one day! If we ever meet in person I'd love to hear your story…

  • Gguess66

    I would love to homeschool Quinton, but I am the one bringing home the primary paycheck in our house so that isn't really an option.

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    That's my fear with my Katelyn. But I know I COULD do it if I had to! Thanks for the encouragement

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    I agree, mom. I'll keep praying for the right decision!

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    I plan on doing that! There's a homeschool expo each April as well and we have to go to the one next year. I”m sure I'll get lots of info there too.

  • http://trythisnotthat10.blogspot.com Shannon

    I just stumbled across your blog and thought I would comment. I was homeschooled for a couple of years and I loved it. My parents used the A Beka Program and I would highly recommend it. (It is a Christian based program) I did end up going to “regular” school eventually and I am thankful for that, but a lot of kids are fine with being homeschooled the whole time. We were very involved in my church and I think as long as you have a good church foundation, homeschooling is definitely something you should look into.

  • http://www.perrymanponderings.blogspot.com Stephanie Perryman

    I totally understand your reservations about homeschooling, especially since you don't have a good support group. I really hope that we are able to home school by the time Brooklyn is at the age of going to school. We have a lot of homeschool communities around here so even if I can't start my own, I can join one. I think you could make it work up there if you decided to do it but don't beat yourself up if you decide it's too much. It's not for everyone.

    I just happened to see this post on one of the blogs I follow today. It's all about setting up your homeschooling room. Hers is totally awesome. Just thought you would enjoy looking at it.

    http://www.aholyexperience.com/2010/08/best-way...

  • Trishq

    I think homeschooling is a very personal decision between you and your children. All children are different and learn in different ways and homeschooling gives you a chance to explore that. All that being said. I personally wouldn't home school my children for several reasons.
    1. my kids need to get out. They torture each other and it's good for them to have a place to go to get away from each other, makes them appreciate each other more.
    2. School prepares kids for the real world. In reality, we have to deal with people every day with different beliefs, values and lifestyles. Instead of sheltering our children from that, I want my children to learn to live with these people. My job is to teach them right from wrong and hope that they can get out there and remember what I taught them.
    3.Routine is important. One day my kids will have work and the will have to get up, get dressed, and be out the door for there jobs. For that reason alone, the very act of going to school everyday is very valuable.
    4. As a christian, we are the light of the world. If we don't communicate and be friends with unbelievers on a regular basis, how will we ever lead them to Christ?
    5. Schools have so many resources available now for issues like learning disabilities, ADHD, speech, reading issues. If there are learning issues with my children, a teacher is much better able to assess those issue than I am.

    I just wanted to give you my view. I really respect people who can successfully home school. I would never have the patience. In the end, you will make the decision that is best for you and your children. There is no right or wrong thing to do.

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    Agreed! And I say “in this day and age all the time” and I'm certainly not old. Ahem. :o D

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    That's a good point, Heather! I really shouldn't base what it's like now at almost 5 in trying to teach Katelyn to what it will be like a year from now. Even if we do butt heads I don't think that's a reason to NOT give it a shot.

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    If Christian private school were an option I'd totally look at that too. But I can't afford it! I am going to look into co-ops for this area. I would definitely feel more of a sense of community that way. Good luck with finding a school for Evan. At least we have year still!

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    Thanks! Living in Brazil was amazing and I wouldn't trade my experience of being a missionary kid for anything! We lived there for 15 years. Left when I graduated from high school. We know several families(including my aunt and uncle) who adopted Brazilian children. There are also a ton of Brazilians here in MA so I have several Brazilian friends. There are even some at our church so it's great to be able to speak Portuguese to them and have a little reminder of my old life :o ) Thanks for commenting!

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    Aww.. that's tough. Maybe it will work out for you one day!

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    We used A Beka! I also remember it being “hard”. It wasn't a super easy program, that's for sure. We do have a good church foundation and are very involved so my girls do get a lot of interaction there. Plus, they are doing dance and my oldest is doing soccer this year.

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    oh, and thanks for stopping by too! Nice to meet you!

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    I loved that room! Thanks for sharing the link. It's amazing.

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    I agree with everything you wrote, but, I think it's possible to be able to do those things and still homeschool! Plus, I feel like I don't need to prepare them for “the real world” this young just yet. They will learn all of that stuff eventually. And being a light is something we all have to work at regardless of how we school our children. That's not something I'm worried about just yet either, when they are still so young. I would definitely think of those issues as they got closer to junior high.

  • http://thedabblerpresents.wordpress.com Heather

    This is great! I'm intrigued by homeschooling even though I'm not religious — I'm wary about overcrowded schools focused on standardized tests and I hope my kids will love learning (I feel like I learned how to test in school – I didn't really develop a love of learning or foster my creativity). I enjoyed reading the comments, too. Ultimately I am lucky to live in a county with a couple of Montessori charter schools that we may be able to get into, but there are many people seeking an alternative to “regular school,” so there are wait-lists. Hope you'll post about what you decide to do — and you can always lie to the busy-bodies or just shut them down when they want to poke around in your business. That's a good example for your kids, anyway — “Mommy is assertive and trusts her instincts, and you should too!” :)

  • http://eco-novice.blogspot.com/ Betsy (Eco-novice)

    Yes, I think the whole figuring out a curriculum and all that is the most daunting. But there seem to be tons of resources online. So many bloggers are homeschoolers! I think the biggest pro reason (after a better education for your kids) is the flexibility.

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    I have the questions and issues with the public school system that you do. AS of now I live in a town that is small and has a good school system from what my friends say. So, at least I have a good option of sending my girls to public school. I will definitely post about what I plan to do. I'm sure I'll do more homsechooling posts when I find interesting blogs about it. Thanks for the comment!

  • http://www.simplymelsblog.com/ Simply Mel

    Yes, I find trying to find a good curriculum and figuring out a good schedule to keep us on the track the more intimidating aspects. And the flexibility, efficient use of time and easier pace are really attractive to me!
    Thanks for the input!

blog comments powered by Disqus